Looking for trusted insurance brokers in Orillia? At PetleyHare, we make insurance easier by comparing coverage from multiple leading insurance providers, so you don't have to shop around on your own. Whether you're looking for home, auto, business, or recreational insurance, we'll explain your options in plain language and help you choose coverage that fits your needs.
We proudly serve Orillia by phone, video, and online, with in-person support available through our Oshawa, Port Perry, and Coboconk offices.
Insurance Help for Orillia Homes, Properties, and Businesses
Insurance isn't one-size-fits-all. We take the time to understand what you're protecting, compare coverage from multiple insurers, explain the trade-offs between policies, and help you make a confident decision. As a local family business with more than 100 years of experience, we believe insurance should be simple, personal, and easy to understand.
Whether you're renewing your policy, switching insurance companies, buying your first home, or reviewing your coverage after a life change, our brokers are here to help. You can reach us by phone, email, or online, without the call centre runaround.
Learn more about the insurers we work with.
Your Insurance Options in Orillia
Whether you're protecting your home, your business, or your favourite weekend getaway vehicle, we'll help you compare coverage that fits your lifestyle.
Auto Insurance
Whether you're commuting throughout Simcoe County or enjoying weekends around Lake Couchiching, your insurance should reflect how you use your vehicle. We'll explain deductibles, liability limits, and optional coverages so you know exactly what you're choosing.
- Auto Insurance
Coverage for everyday drivers, with options based on how you use your vehicle. - Classic Car Insurance
Coverage designed for collector vehicles, with considerations for value and usage. - RV Insurance
Protection for motorhomes, trailers, and campers.
Business Insurance
Running a business comes with enough responsibilities without wondering whether your insurance keeps up. We help business owners compare coverage that protects their operations, property, equipment, and liability. Many businesses also require proof of insurance for contracts, leases, or tenders, and we can help with that too.
- Business Insurance
Flexible coverage tailored to your day-to-day operations. - Builders Risk Insurance
Protection for materials and structures during construction or renovations. - Commercial Property Insurance
Coverage for buildings, contents, and business interruptions. - Construction Insurance
Insurance designed for active projects and job sites. - Contractor Insurance
Coverage that can help protect tools, equipment, and liability. - Farm Insurance
Insurance solutions for agricultural operations. - Group Insurance
Benefits options that support your employees.
Home Insurance
Whether you own a detached home, condo, rental property, or seasonal cottage, your insurance should reflect how you use your property. We'll walk you through your options so you understand what's covered before you make a decision.
- Home Insurance
Coverage for your home, belongings, and personal liability. - Condo Insurance
Protection that complements your condominium corporation's master policy. - Cottage Insurance
Coverage for seasonal and secondary properties. - Tenant Insurance
Protection for your belongings and personal liability while renting.
Recreation Insurance
From weekends on the water to adventures on the road, we'll help you compare coverage for the recreational vehicles you enjoy most.
- Boat Insurance
Coverage based on how and where you use your boat. - Toy Insurance
Coverage for recreational vehicles such as ATVs and snowmobiles.
Other Insurance
Some situations call for specialized coverage. We can also help arrange insurance for unique personal and business needs.
- Cyber Insurance
Protection against cyber threats and digital risks. - Drone Insurance
Coverage for recreational and commercial drone use. - Yoga Instructor Insurance
Insurance designed for instructors and wellness professionals.
Why Orillia Clients Choose PetleyHare
Choosing insurance shouldn't feel complicated. As an independent brokerage, we work with multiple insurance companies, giving you more choice and personalized advice instead of a one-size-fits-all solution.
Clients choose PetleyHare because we offer:
- Independent advice and access to multiple insurers
- Friendly, straightforward guidance without confusing jargon
- Personalized service from experienced brokers
- Support as your insurance needs change
- Claims guidance when you need it most
A first-time homebuyer has different priorities than a contractor growing their business or a retiree reviewing long-time coverage. That's why we take the time to understand your situation before recommending options.
If you'd like to know more about the people behind PetleyHare, read our story.
Local Insurance Considerations for Orillia
Your insurance should reflect how you live and work. Whether you're commuting throughout Simcoe County, enjoying weekends at a nearby cottage, or operating a local business, those details can influence the type of coverage that's right for you.
If anything has changed since your last renewal, such as moving, renovating, buying a new vehicle, or expanding your business, it's a good time to review your policy. Small updates can make a big difference when it comes to making sure your coverage still fits your needs.
Need to make a change? Update your policy or speak with one of our brokers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do You Provide Insurance for Orillia Residents?
Yes. We regularly help clients throughout Orillia by phone, email, and online, with in-person appointments available through our nearby offices in Oshawa, Port Perry, and Coboconk.
Can You Help If My Insurance Renewal Increased?
Absolutely. We’ll compare options from multiple insurers, explain any differences in coverage, and help you decide whether switching or adjusting your policy makes sense.
Does Commuting Affect My Insurance?
It can. How often you drive, how far you travel, and how you use your vehicle are all factors that may affect your coverage. We’ll walk you through what insurers consider when comparing your options.
Do You Offer Business Insurance in Orillia?
Yes. We help business owners compare coverage based on their operations, industry, and insurance requirements. Whether you need liability coverage, commercial property insurance, or proof of insurance for a contract or lease, we’re here to help.
What Do I Need to Get a Quote?
We’ll ask a few questions about what you’d like to insure, along with any current coverage you have. From there, we’ll compare options from multiple insurers and explain them in plain language. Get a quote to get started.
Ready to Get Insurance Help in Orillia?
Whether you're comparing Orillia home insurance, reviewing your current policy, or looking for coverage for your business or vehicle, we're here to help make the process simple.
Get a quote to compare options from multiple insurers, or contact us if you'd like to speak with a broker first. If you need help with an existing policy, you can also start a claim.
Business Insurance Insights
- Don’t Let Flooding Shut You Down: Protect Your Business Before It Hits
Storms and flooding can hit hard, and when they do, everything can grind to a halt. Damaged equipment, lost inventory, ... - Spring Maintenance Tips to Help Prevent Home Insurance Claims
Spring is a time for renewal. The flowers are blooming, the sun is shining, and everything feels new. It's also ... - Home Insurance Renewal: A Simple Guide for Homeowners
Your home insurance renewal can feel like just another email to skim and accept. But it’s actually one of the ...
