Looking for trusted insurance brokers in Peterborough? PetleyHare helps you compare coverage from multiple leading insurance providers, making it easier to find a policy that fits your life, your business, and your budget. Whether you're looking for car insurance in Peterborough, home insurance, business insurance, or coverage for your recreational vehicles, we'll explain your options in plain language and help you make a confident decision. While our offices are in Oshawa, Port Perry, and Coboconk, we proudly serve Peterborough by phone, email, and online.

Real brokers. Clear answers. Coverage that fits Peterborough life.

Get a Quote Contact Us

Pick Your Starting Point in Peterborough

No matter where you are in your insurance journey, we're here to help you move forward with confidence.

  • Looking for a new policy or comparing quotes for the first time?
  • Has your renewal increased and you want to compare your options?
  • Buying a home or condo and need home insurance in Peterborough?
  • Need proof of insurance for a contract, lease, or project?

As an independent insurance brokerage in Peterborough, we'll compare options from multiple insurers and help you understand the differences, so you can choose the coverage that's right for you.

Start Your Quote

How Our Insurance Brokerage Helps Peterborough Clients

Working with PetleyHare is simple.

Tell us what you need. We'll ask a few questions about your home, vehicle, business, or project and what you'd like to protect.

We compare your options. We shop coverage from multiple insurers, explain the trade-offs between policies, and answer your questions without the insurance jargon.

We stay with you. Once your policy is in place, we're here for renewals, policy changes, certificates of insurance, and claims support whenever you need us.

No call centres. Just experienced brokers who are easy to reach.

Learn more about the insurers we work with.

Insurance Options for Peterborough Residents and Businesses

Whether you're protecting your home, your business, or your favourite weekend getaway, we'll help you compare coverage that fits your needs.

Insurance Brokers Serving Peterborough

Car Insurance

Peterborough drivers often have questions about deductibles, commuting, adding new drivers, and optional coverages. We'll explain your choices clearly and help you compare policies that fit your driving habits and budget.

Home Insurance

From family homes and condos to student rentals and cottages throughout the Kawarthas, every property has different insurance needs. We'll help you compare policies, explain common coverages like water protection and liability, and make sure your insurance reflects how you use your property.

Insurance Brokers Serving Peterborough
Insurance Brokers Serving Peterborough

Business Insurance

Whether you operate a retail shop, professional office, farm, or contracting business, we'll help you compare coverage that protects your operations while meeting insurance requirements for contracts, leases, and tenders.

Need proof of insurance quickly? Let us know what's required, and we'll help arrange the correct certificate.

Recreation Insurance

Living near the Kawarthas means weekends often involve boats, trailers, RVs, or ATVs. We can help you coordinate coverage for your recreational vehicles so you can spend more time enjoying them and less time worrying about what's protected.

Insurance Brokers Serving Peterborough
Insurance Brokers Serving Peterborough

Other Insurance

Some insurance needs are more specialized. Whether you operate a drone, manage customer data, or run a wellness business, we'll help you understand your options and arrange coverage that fits your work.

Why Choose PetleyHare for Your Insurance Needs in Peterborough

When you work with PetleyHare, you're working with an independent brokerage that's focused on helping you find the right coverage, not just selling a single insurance product.

  • Access to multiple leading insurance providers.
  • Friendly, straightforward advice without confusing jargon.
  • Real brokers you can reach by phone or email.
  • Help meeting insurance requirements for contracts, leases, and tenders.
  • Ongoing support as your insurance needs change.
  • Claims guidance when you need it most.

As a family business with more than 100 years of history, we're proud to help Ontario families and businesses protect what matters most.

Learn more about our story.

FAQs for Peterborough Insurance Shoppers

Do You Serve Peterborough Even Though Your Offices Are Elsewhere?

Yes. We regularly help clients throughout Peterborough by phone, email, and online while providing the same personalized service.

What Information Do You Need for a Car Insurance Quote?

We’ll ask about your vehicle, driving history, and how you use it so we can compare the right options.

I'm Buying a Condo. What Should I Share?

Basic property details and information about your condominium corporation’s insurance will help us recommend appropriate coverage.

My Renewal Increased. Can You Compare My Options?

Absolutely. We’ll review your current policy, compare options from multiple insurers, and explain the differences before you decide.

What Insurance Do Contractors Commonly Need?

Requirements vary, but many contracts and job sites require liability coverage and proof of insurance. We’ll help you understand what’s needed.

Have another question? If your circumstances have changed, you can also update your policy.

Get a Quote from Reliable Insurance Brokers in Peterborough

If you're looking for straightforward advice and insurance options that fit your needs, we're here to help. Compare coverage from multiple insurers with experienced brokers who make the process simple from start to finish.

Get a Quote Contact Us

Need help with an existing policy? You can also start a claim online.

Business Insurance Insights